Is this HJ Rudolstadt tinnie a fake?

[Carlyle]

You don't have permission to view attachments.

You don't have permission to view attachments.

I’ve never seen this version before and something doesn’t feel right about it to me.
Joe

 

[railhouse]

Hi never seen this version

You don't have permission to view attachments.

 

[Carlyle]

Hi never seen this version

You don't have permission to view attachments.

What do you think of this one Railhouse?

 

[railhouse]

I dont like it

 

[mkholst]

Hi Railhouse - you write that you don't like it, but not WHY - what do you think is wrong with it??

Hi Carlyle - I noticed that it was not punched out but cast in solid (flat back). Most of this tinnie that I have seen is pounched out.

BUT I have found one that, like yours, is flat on the back. The needle on yours seems to have been replaced with one that doesn't really fit.

You don't have permission to view attachments.

I just think I want to contribute a little to this thread.

Michael

 

[Carlyle]

I dont like it

Darn. It didn’t look good to me either. I got it with 6 other tinnies that haven’t arrived yet.

 

[Carlyle]

Hi Railhouse - you write that you don't like it, but not WHY - what do you think is wrong with it??

Hi Carlyle - I noticed that it was not punched out but cast in solid (flat back). Most of this tinnie that I have seen is pounched out.

BUT I have found one that, like yours, is flat on the back. The needle on yours seems to have been replaced with one that doesn't really fit.

You don't have permission to view attachments.

I just think I want to contribute a little to this thread.

Michael

thanks Michael I’m always glad to here from you and I value your opinion.
Joe